Moscow, Russia/Kyiv, Ukraine
Reuters
A senior Russian lawmaker said Ukrainian military intelligence had been given a 15-minute warning before a Russian military transport plane carrying Ukrainian prisoners of war entered an area where it was shot down on Wednesday, killing all on board.
Moscow accuses Kyiv of downing the Ilyushin Il-76 plane in Russia’s Belgorod region, killing 74 people on board, including 65 captured Ukrainian soldiers en route to be swapped for Russian PoWs.
A view shows the crash site of the Russian Ilyushin Il-76 military transport plane near the village of Yablonovo in the Belgorod region, Russia, in this still image from video published on 25th January, 2024. PICTURE: Russian Investigative Committee/Handout via Reuters
Russia’s Investigative Committee said on Thursday the plane was struck by a Ukrainian-made surface-to-air missile.
Ukraine denied that it was given a warning. It has neither confirmed nor denied that its forces downed the plane but has challenged details of Moscow’s account and called for an international investigation.
“The Ukrainian side was officially warned, and 15 minutes before the plane entered the zone they were given complete information,” Andrei Kartopolov, a former general with close ties to Russia’s defence ministry, told lawmakers, according to the ruling United Russia party. He said Ukraine’s military command confirmed receipt of the warning.
His assertion contradicted statements by Ukrainian military intelligence that Russia had not informed it about the flight arrangements.
Ukrainian military intelligence spokesperson Andriy Yusov, said that contrary to practice before previous PoW swaps, Kyiv had received no requests from Russia to refrain from attacks in the airspace where the plane was downed. He challenged Moscow’s version of events.
“No evidence has been provided for the charges…Nothing has been shown to prove the wreckage and the presence of people on board,” he said on national television on Thursday.
Conflicting narratives from both sides are a daily feature of a war now nearing the end of its second year. In this case the stakes are especially high, as it is the deadliest incident of its kind on internationally recognised Russian territory since Russia’s February, 2022, invasion.
“Provocation”
At 11:33am on Wednesday, the Russian defence ministry published a report of a Ukrainian drone being shot down by air defences in the region. Reports of a plane crashing emerged on social media minutes later.
Yusov said Ukraine had been using reconnaissance drones in the area, and that Russia had launched attack drones. There was “no confirmed information” that Ukraine had hit any targets, he said.
“Unfortunately, we can assume various scenarios, including provocation, as well as the use of Ukrainian prisoners as a human shield for transporting ammunition and weapons for S-300 systems (being used in the war),” he told Radio Svoboda.
Fragments of what appeared to be a missile have been found at the site where the plane crashed in Russia’s southwestern Belgorod region near the border with Ukraine, the TASS state news agency cited emergency services as saying on Thursday.
In a statement posted on the Telegram messenger app, Russian investigators said their “preliminary” conclusion was that the plane had been hit by an anti-aircraft missile from the Zenit rocket family, and a criminal investigation had been opened.
A view shows the crash site of the Russian Ilyushin Il-76 military transport plane near the village of Yablonovo in the Belgorod region, Russia, in this still image from video published on 25th January, 2024. PICTURE: Russian Investigative Committee/Handout via Reuters
Ukraine said it had opened its own investigation into a potential violation of the rules of war. President Volodymyr Zelenskiy said on Wednesday that greater clarity was needed, particularly when it came to who was on board, and he accused Russia of “playing with the lives of Ukrainian prisoners”.
Russia has sole access to the site of the crash, where TV pictures showed debris scattered over snowy fields. TASS said the plane’s flight recorders had been recovered and would be flown to Moscow for examination.
We rely on our readers to fund Sight's work - become a financial supporter today!
For more information, head to our Subscriber's page.
Ukraine’s human rights commissioner Dmytro Lubinets told Reuters he believed the incident was a planned Russian misinformation campaign. He said a list of Ukrainian PoW casualties, which was shared after the crash by Russian media, included soldiers already returned in a previous swap.
“The Russians will make loud statements but will not allow anyone in. They will not hand over any materials for analysis and will simply blame Ukraine,” he told national television.
The United Nations Security Council was due to convene at 2200 GMT on Thursday in response to a Russian call for a meeting to establish “the reasons behind the Ukrainian criminal act”.
France, a permanent member of the Security Council, said it was in no position to tell whether Russia’s assertions about the incident were true.
However, deputy foreign ministry spokesperson Christophe Lemoine told a weekly briefing that the international community was used to Russia “lying on these matters”.
