SUBSCRIBE NOW

SIGHT

Be informed. Be challenged. Be inspired.

DEATH PENALTY: POPE LAYS DOWN CHALLENGE ON CAPITAL PUNISHMENT

Death Penalty

CHRISTOPHER LAMB reports for Religion News Service on Pope Francis’ opposition to the use of the death penalty…

RNS

When Pope Francis visited the United States two years ago, he spoke out against the death penalty in speeches to Congress and the United Nations.

Earlier this month he went a step further, calling for a revision of official church teaching that would make capital punishment “inadmissible”. It was an historic shift given that the death penalty has, until now, been allowed by the church in certain circumstances. 

The death penalty, Pope Francis explained during an important speech in the Vatican on 11th October, is “contrary to the Gospel, because it entails the willful suppression of a human life that never ceases to be sacred in the eyes of its Creator”.

Death Penalty

The lethal injection room at San Quentin State Prison in California in 2010. PICTURE: Creative Commons/CA Corrections

 

The death penalty, Pope Francis explained during an important speech in the Vatican on 11th October, is “contrary to the Gospel, because it entails the willful suppression of a human life that never ceases to be sacred in the eyes of its Creator”.

With these words, the Pope is also reshaping what it means to be “pro-life”. He is moving it away from primarily opposing abortion and stressing that it means protecting life at every stage, from womb to natural death. 

It is in the US where the Pope’s words may have the most impact, given punishment by death is still legal in more than 30 states and is supported by close to half of all Catholics. According to a 2016 Pew Research poll, 43 per cent of American Catholics support the death penalty, while 46 per cent are opposed. And abortion remains a highly polarising issue. 

Among those welcoming the Pope’s words was Sister Helen Prejean, whose work on death row was dramatised in the Oscar-nominated film Dead Man Walking, with her role played by Susan Sarandon. 

“At last, a clear, uncompromising stance of moral opposition to the death penalty by the highest authority of the church,” she told America magazine. 

There are many more-traditional Catholics who argue forcefully in favor of the death penalty. Joseph M Bessette and Edward Feser argue that “for extremely heinous crimes, no lesser punishment could possibly respect this Catholic principle that a punishment ought to be proportional to the offense.”

Defenders of the death penalty on religious grounds also point to the argument from St Thomas Aquinas, the renowned church teacher, that sometimes it is permissible in order to promote the common good and keep people safe.  

According to the Catholic catechism, the death penalty is allowed if it is “the only possible way of effectively defending human lives against the unjust aggressor”. Yet it goes on to say that the times when the death penalty is “absolutely necessary” are “very rare, if not practically nonexistent”.

In the US, this is a teaching that finds sympathy not only among conservatives.

A number of liberal Catholics are also uncomfortable with the idea of a church ban on capital punishment, said Massimo Faggioli, a church historian and theology professor at Villanova University. 

“The Europe-America divide on the death penalty is deeper than we think,” Prof Faggioli told RNS. 

In reality, the Pope’s ruling had been a long time coming. Both Benedict XVI and John Paul II condemned its use, although they stopped short of making any change to official teaching. 

Pope Francis has now said the catechism should be updated to take into account his predecessors’ interventions and a “change in the awareness of the Christian people”.

In his speech last week to a group of senior prelates gathered in the Vatican, who were marking 25 years since the latest version of the catechism was promulgated, he said the death penalty “is an inhumane measure that, regardless of how it is carried out, abases human dignity.”

“The Europe-America divide on the death penalty is deeper than we think.”

– Massimo Faggioli, a church historian and theology professor at Villanova University in the US.

The church, he stressed, had made “progress” from the days when capital punishment was used by the papal states – the lands controlled by the papacy from around the eighth century until the late 19th. 

“Let us take responsibility for the past,” the Pope said. “And recognise that the imposition of the death penalty was dictated by a mentality more legalistic than Christian.”

Throughout his almost five-year papacy, Pope Francis has consistently stressed the importance of God’s mercy, and in particular how this applies to prisoners. Twice a month, on Sunday afternoons, the Pope phones inmates in an Argentine prison. And he has said that whenever he visits a prison he thinks to himself: “I, too, could be here.” 

His death penalty change is part of a wider vision calling for a justice system focused on rehabilitation rather than punishment. Or as Oscar Wilde said: “Every saint has a past, and every sinner a future.”

The changes on capital punishment might not be the only area where Francis is preparing to evolve teaching. The Pope has called for a revision of just war theory, which sets out moral conditions that justify a military intervention. This ancient teaching, which has been revised and updated over the years, is not just used by the church but by many generals who see it as a useful guide on when to resort to force. 

In Rome, a senior cardinal, Peter Turkson, has called for just war teaching to be abolished and has said the pope could write an encyclical letter, a major papal document, reorienting the church’s position on the matter.

For Pope Francis, there should be a consistent life ethic – the notion that there is a “seamless garment” to what the church says about abortion, the death penalty and nonviolence.

By revising the death penalty position, the Pope apparently feels he is not merely developing doctrine but also highlighting a deeper Catholic vision of what it means to protect human life.

Christopher Lamb is The Tablet’s Rome correspondent and a contributor to RNS.

 

Donate



sight plus logo

Sight+ is a new benefits program we’ve launched to reward people who have supported us with annual donations of $26 or more. To find out more about Sight+ and how you can support the work of Sight, head to our Sight+ page.

Musings

TAKE PART IN THE SIGHT READER SURVEY!

We’re interested to find out more about you, our readers, as we improve and expand our coverage and so we’re asking all of our readers to take this survey (it’ll only take a couple of minutes).

To take part in the survey, simply follow this link…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

For security, use of Google's reCAPTCHA service is required which is subject to the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.