BOOKS: THE EYE OF THE NEEDLE - DISCIPLESHIP AND WEALTH

10th January, 2006
LLOYD HARKNESS

The Eye of the Needle: Discipleship and Wealth

Jim Reiher
Published by Urban Neighbours of Hope

ISBN 0 9580602 4 X

 

"Written as a response to a growing version of the 'prosperity doctrine' (God wants every Christian to escape a poverty mindset, be rich and prosper His kingdom) in Australia, this book is a simple and thorough Biblical exposition of God's New Testament, or new covenant, position on money."

I will start this review by drawing two quick portraits, of which there could be a thousand variations, and setting you three questions to consider.

Person A. Successful in business, I have always applied the principle 'what you sow you reap'. I have tithed to my local church and given extra to visiting ministries. God has prospered me and my God's desire is to prosper you too.

Person B. I am a wage earner whose income doesn't always keep pace with inflation. God provides for me but I'm never going to own a house on a hill. I work at maintaining a generous spirit so I can give to people and organisations that are bringing honour to Jesus. God is my provider and He will be your provider too.

Questions.
1. Which person do you identify with the most?
2. What do you identify with?
3. Who do you theologically agree with?

Whatever your response was to the three questions I daresay it wasn't the first time you have thought about God and money. Jim Reiher (who writes Sight's Life's Tough Questions column) has pondered this issue long and hard too. The Eye of the Needle is a substantive 140-page treatise of, as the subtitle tells us, the question of discipleship and wealth.

Written as a response to a growing version of the 'prosperity doctrine' (God wants every Christian to escape a poverty mindset, be rich and prosper His kingdom) in Australia, this book is a simple and thorough Biblical exposition of God's New Testament, or new covenant, position on money.

Jim's stated purpose is to correct an error "that can lead to self centredness, pride, envy and greed". In a generation where people seem to be searching for a simple formula so that everything in life works for me, the 'prosperity doctrine' has found it's own niche.

However, life is about relationships. Life can also be messy and incongruous with its share of anomalies. Looking for security in a formula isn't going to help you live life. The 'prosperity doctrine' is an empty promise and the problem with all empty promises is the devastating effect on those who once believed them. I am just warming up but I'll stop now and let Jim address these and other money matters.

Hopefully this book will help everyone who reads it to put wealth in its correct perspective and so be more effective disciples.

Chapter eight helped to break up the book with its different approach. The reader is asked to meditate on some key scriptures dealing with money. You then read Jim's 'prosperity' version. The sarcasm, while being a little sharper than an Adrian Plass, certainly has a way of cutting through the pompous and the ridiculous.

And that is what you get in The Eye of the Needle - a good, Godly, scriptural, Australian, down-to-earth, matter-of-fact discussion of prosperity.

FOR MORE ON BOOKS, visit our books page here...


Your Say

Comment left by Ray Morel-Grace AOG
Well done Jim for the strength of your conviction to pen your thoughts on this subject. I am a "prosperity thinker" but my definition of prosperity may be different to others. It is certainly not based on my bank balance. I honestly don't think Brian intended "You need More Money" to be a theology book and we know his heart of generosity to further the cause of Christ. At the end of the day, I am blessed to have Jim as a dear friend as well as having Brian as our movement leader. (The world desperately needs both) In the end I am sure we will all discover that what matters is "Christ" and in accepting Him (and his ways) we will do away with the curse of sin on His much loved world! I cried too many tears watching the last breath of some Kenyan Children recently to ever think of Poverty as a virtue!

PS We use to have the house (Not on the Hill) but sold it to invest in a church plant. We are definately richer for it!
Comment left by BJ
Great news to hear of such a book.

I have alays felt uneasy about the "faith and prosperity" issues, as it denies the suffering of the persecuted church, and demeans their experience of trial as a lack of belief in God's desire to prosprer them.
I know of men who suffered in prison for thir faith, only recieved one slice of bread a day, giving away every tenth slice as a tithe to God.
Comment left by jk
Just finished the book. I love it. I really like the way the author of this book does not demonize Brian Houston. He clearly disagrees with Houston on the issue of Prosperity and tithing, but he says a number of times that Hillsong has done good things in other areas, and that Brian is not as extreme a Prosperity Teacher as some others doing the circut, etc. That gracious attitude that carefully distinguishes between someone like Brian Houston and others like the Copelands and Avazini's of the world, is commendable. It's a book worth reading.


Discuss this article.

Name:

Message:


Enter your name and message to make a comment. You may need to refresh the page to see your message appear.
Due to recent spam problems, messages that contain links are moderated before they will appear.